My friend James and I hadn’t talked in a while, but he wrote me a letter this summer.

I tucked it away in a book on my shelf—one of my favorite books, with a ratty blue cover and a bleeding highlighter rainbow soaking through every page.

Honestly…I was slow to read that letter. I didn’t want to commit. I’d sit on my couch in the dark living room, curling my toes on the squishy gray rug, wanting nothing more than to tune out and relax. I’d just discovered a new TV show. I’m always discovering a new TV show. And that’s not an issue, of course, until it keeps me from the letters. Until I’m reminded of my friend James, and how badly he wanted to talk to me.

So I’d sigh, and haul off the couch, and read another line of that letter I’d tucked away.

After all, he’d taken the time to write it.

That’s got to count for something.

The cave.

When I was little, I really didn’t like being the little sister. I think maybe that’s how all little sisters are—especially when they’re the only sister. “What do you mean I’m little? I’m the biggest sister here!”

But I was small and thin, with large, brown, cow eyes. I’d wear my hair in pigtails, and my shirts were all glittery and my shoes never stayed on my feet, and I was fine being on my own. I had plenty of imaginary worlds to keep me occupied, after all. My room was filled with portals.

I’d sit on the bottom bunk of my and my brother’s bed, and sliiiiiiiiide shut the pink floral curtains my mom had made me and hung off the top mattress frame. In the cool, silent, coral-tinged dark, I’d reach over and switch on my bedside lamp. As my cave of wonders illuminated, I’d pat my striped sheets smooth and line up all my stuffed animals at the foot of the bed. They were all people to me. Characters.

The white wolf was a pirate, of course. Jack—the only suitable name for a good-hearted scurvy dog. His long, matted fur and stone-lion posture made him the perfect swashbuckler.

The tiger, well, he was a different kind of rascally rogue. His long, gangly arms meant he was great at thieving. His name was Theo. He was from San Diego, and he hadn’t been the plushie I’d wanted and had clearly never lived that fact down. He made up for it by picking pockets, and also leading a revolution against the evil king, Hamish, who was both man and frog (and puppet).

I’d spend hours, perfectly content, on my bed, in that fantasy place where I knew all the people by name. Where I knew all the answers.

I know!

It’s not that I didn’t play well with others.

However, “others” were usually older than me, like my brother and his friends. They were all so cool, with their Nerf guns, and Marvel baseball caps, and Star Wars LEGO sets.

I remember once, when I was maybe six or seven, I was sitting in my friend’s bedroom with my back to that giant sliding mirror of a closet door. Ian and Emma—they were like Sam and me. Big brother, little sister, one bedroom with a bunk bed.

I don’t remember if Emma was there or not, but I know I was sitting there cross-legged on the beige carpet, watching Ian and my brother talk about whatever little boys talk about. I was facing the bunk bed…I think Ian had the bottom bunk, even though he was older. I turned away from the messy, outer-space-patterned sheets and started eyeing the books on the little, overcrowded shelf to my left.

Big books.

Big words.

I counted all the pretty blue-green ones. They all had the same name on the spine. Percy Jackson? That must be a book for big kids, because I hadn’t heard of it.

Ian started telling me something. I frowned at him to prove I was listening. It’s anyone’s guess as to what he was talking about—Star Wars, or Bionicles, or something about some historic battle with the Romans—whatever it was, he ended his sentence with a comment that suggested that I hadn’t heard this information before.

I scrunched my brow and leaned back on my hands.

“I know,” I said, voice all high and tight as if I was lying under oath. And I said it with no hesitation. No thought. The words tumbled right out of me like a reflex—like some doctor had jumped out of the closet behind me and tapped my knee with a tiny hammer.

Even then, I wondered to myself when I’d gotten so good at lying.

Because I was.

I was lying.

I mean, I knew what Ian was saying. I understood the words and the context, and that it was facts about something or other that he was into. But they were facts I hadn’t known before. I hadn’t known.

But this heat welled up inside me the second I defended myself—because that’s what it was, a defense. I’m not stupid. Ignorance isn’t cool, here. I know things—I’m the little sister but I know things.

And that moment in my friend’s room, all those years ago, has no real reason to be so memorable. And it’s not like I recall what was said, exactly, or why.

And yet I remember that moment so crystal clear. The floor, the carpet, the sliding mirror door, the LEGOs on the dresser. My high pitched I know and the desperation to be seen as smart.

What is wisdom?

I’m not sure when, at so young an age, I got it into my head that when you don’t know something, the people who teach you do it to prove that you’re stupid. That correction is negative. That growth requires shame.

Perhaps that’s why I screened James’s calls, so to speak. He’s a good friend, I know, but he’s a better teacher. He doesn’t pull punches. I thought that meant I’d get a black eye.

But he’d taken the time to write to me, and that showed me that he doesn’t go for the face. He goes for the heart. For the soul. Those are much more absorbing than the skull. They’re meant to be punched, sometimes.

So back to the couch I’d go, in my dark living room, but this time with his letter unfolded in my lap.

“Who is wise and understanding?” he said. “The wise should do his job with the meekness of wisdom.”

“Meekness?” I leaned back on the couch. “What, the wise should just…roll over for the people who disagree?” I’m always eager to catch James in a lie.

“Real wisdom is humble. It’s not selfish, Lucy,” he continued. “It’s not jealous—otherwise you’d get disorder and chaos. Real wisdom is peaceable, reasonable, merciful. If you want peace, make it.“

I soaked that in for a bit, staring across at my dark reflection in the dead TV. “But I don’t want to scare people away by making peace,” I grumbled. “That makes it sound like…that I don’t care what other people think.”

James wrote on like he knew what I was thinking. “Would you be friends with the world? Will you put their love and respect above that of God?”

I sighed. “That’s not what we were talking about,” I muttered…

“You’re adulterous, that’s what. Friendship with the world? Come on, Lucy. You can’t be friends with the world and with God. Did you know that?”

I wanted to say Yeah James, I know.

And maybe a little part of me did know.

But as I sat in the silence, I realized that he wouldn’t tell me these things if he didn’t want me to get better. I didn’t have to pretend to know things ahead of time—he was there to tell me. Not to prove I was dumb, but to fill me in on the big truths of life. Even if he’s blunt and out of my control. Even if he doesn’t fit into my fantasy realities and games.

He doesn’t expect me to figure it all out on my own, and he’s there to tell me what’s up.

There’s so much love in a teacher like that.

He wants me to be better.

I smiled as I folded up the letter. I set it on the coffee table and drew in a breath.

“Now I know,” I said. “Thank you.”


sunspot-free-fantasy-dark-romance-tragedy-short-story

Want a free short story?

Of course you do! You're in luck, because I have a story called Sunspot for you!

Fill out the form and have the PDF sent straight to your inbox.

The story is on it's way to your inbox!